Business Opening Hours

Monday12:00 PM06:00 PM
Tuesday12:00 PM07:00 PM
Wednesday12:00 PM08:00 PM
Thursday10:00 AM02:00 PM
Friday12:00 PM06:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM06:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM06:00 PM

Sign up for General Email, Shipping Updates and Special Offers.

Letting us know your whereabouts helps in keeping you up to date in area-specific news, or keeps you from getting emails that might not pertain to you.
Letting us know your whereabouts helps in keeping you up to date in area-specific news, or keeps you from getting emails that might not pertain to you.
* = required field


Thanksgiving Hours:

  • Today, Red Hook ONLY, 10:00 AM till at least 2:00 PM, DeKalb will is closed.


Victim Films, Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie.

Victim Films, Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie. -click image to watch-


Making a great key lime pie isn’t rocket science. So why is finding an authentic key lime pie such a difficult task?

The answer is really quite simple. Too many bakeries and bakers cut corners, using a pre-made crust or bottled juice from concentrates, mechanizing every aspect of production in order to optimize the bottom line, or because a key lime pie is just another offering in a long line of products

At Steve’s Authentic, we know what makes a great key lime pie, and for over 20 years we have devoted ourselves to recreating that timeless classic dessert for the public the very way Steve did as a young man growing up in South Florida for family and friends.

According to the American Pie Council, only two commercial bakeries in the US use fresh squeezed key lime juice -hint, neither are located in Florida- something we consider a “key” ingredient. Bottled juice -reconstituted from concentrates and chemically preserved- is fine for stripping paint or removing rust, but doesn’t belong in a food product.

We make a hand formed crust using nothing more than specially formulated premium Graham cracker crumbs (free of trans-fats and high fructose corn syrup) blended with nothing more than 100% pure butter. Our filling uses Wisconsin dairy fresh sweetened and condensed milk, cage-free egg yolks and our fresh squeezed key lime juice. Like we said, this isn’t rocket science. It’s no wonder Al Roker called Steve’s Authentic “One of the Last Genuine Key Lime Pies in the US” and Amanda Hesser of the NY Times said ours was “The Best Key Lime Pie, Mason Dixon Line or No.”

Don’t be taken by buffoons who hawk their pies on the streets of Key West wearing clown suits or doing a dog-and-pony show, better yet, ask to visit the bakery when they’re juicing their key limes.  Always best to seek out authenticity and integrity.

All the Keys to a great pie? From Soldier Key to Key West to the Dry Tortugas, there lives a spirit of individualism, integrity and authenticity. In what we do here at Steve’s Authentic, we have All the Keys, to a Great Pie.

Please follow our links for more specific information.

Keep up with our  Instagram and Facebook pages

Thanks to FLICKR friend Tom (aka KeyLargo_Diver) for some of our banner images.