Our Red Hook location. This is by far the best option for getting our product, as we always make sure the pies are at their freshest.
If you’ve never been here, we suggest you take a jaunt to our little corner of Brooklyn. We are adjacent to Valentino Park, literally the closest vantage point to the Statue of Liberty in NYC, with the exception of Governors’s Island.
Aside from the full regalia of pies (4-8-10 inch), our Red Hook location is the only place where you can purchase our gluten-free version and the ever-so-popular Swingle™, that frozen upon a stick, Belgian chocolate-dipped key lime tart. The Classic, The Raspberry, The Raspberry Blonde and the La Victoria. We also serve key-limonade, lightly sweetened and guaranteed to put you a pucker on your face.
We put extra effort in making sure the pies we sell here are at their prime, but if you’re on the road or carrying them on a trip —they’ve flown successfully to the Far East and Europe— we do have a flash-frozen option. To check store hours, please go back to our home page. Keep in mind, during the summer months we try and stay open later than posted hours, especially on nice days and weekends.
There’s plenty to do and see while you’re here. Check out our directions page where you’ll find a link for the New York Water Taxi’s Ikea Express, which debarks just a short walk from us.